The Missing Layers: Integrating Sociocultural Values Into Marine Spatial Planning
Maria Grazia Pennino
Stephanie Brodie
André Frainer
Priscila F. M. Lopes
Jon Lopez
Kelly Ortega-Cisneros
Samiya Ahmed Selim
Natasa Vaidianu
Abstract
Marine Spatial Planning (MSP) is a relatively new approach to ocean management and has been widely implemented worldwide. Ideally, MSP should be established as a public process that analyzes and distributes human activities across space and time to achieve ecological, economic and social goals, which historically have been accomplished exclusively in the political arena. However, in most cases MSP seems to be driven primarily by economic interests rather than by sociocultural goals. In this paper, we discuss how integrating the missing sociocultural layers into MSP can help to reduce governance rigidity, promote adaptability in decision-making, support environmental justice, and improve MSP acceptance and uptake. In particular, we focus on identifying possible points of connection between MSP and frameworks based on social-ecological system theory, including co-management and other democratic and empowering alternatives. We conclude by proposing a new definition of the MSP process that is more inclusive, and mindful of users’ rights and sociocultural objectives. If we bridge the gap between the dominant economic rhetoric and a de facto sociocultural-ecological system approach, we are likely to improve the chances of the MSP process succeeding on both the human and nature fronts.
Pennino M.G., Brodie S., Frainer A., Lopes P.F.M., Lopez J., Ortega-Cisneros K., Selim S.A. and Vaidianu N. (2021) The Missing Layers: Integrating Sociocultural Values Into Marine Spatial Planning. Frontiers in Marine Science 8. 10.3389/fmars.2021.633198
@article{Pennino2021,
Title = {The Missing Layers: Integrating Sociocultural Values Into Marine Spatial Planning},
Author = {Pennino, Maria Grazia and Brodie, Stephanie and Frainer, André and Lopes, Priscila F. M. and Lopez, Jon and Ortega-Cisneros, Kelly and Selim, Samiya Ahmed and Vaidianu, Natasa},
Editor = {},
Journal = {Frontiers in Marine Science},
Year = {2021},
Volume = {8},
Doi = {10.3389/fmars.2021.633198},
Abstract = {Marine Spatial Planning (MSP) is a relatively new approach to ocean management and has been widely implemented worldwide. Ideally, MSP should be established as a public process that analyzes and distributes human activities across space and time to achieve ecological, economic and social goals, which historically have been accomplished exclusively in the political arena. However, in most cases MSP seems to be driven primarily by economic interests rather than by sociocultural goals. In this paper, we discuss how integrating the missing sociocultural layers into MSP can help to reduce governance rigidity, promote adaptability in decision-making, support environmental justice, and improve MSP acceptance and uptake. In particular, we focus on identifying possible points of connection between MSP and frameworks based on social-ecological system theory, including co-management and other democratic and empowering alternatives. We conclude by proposing a new definition of the MSP process that is more inclusive, and mindful of users’ rights and sociocultural objectives. If we bridge the gap between the dominant economic rhetoric and a de facto sociocultural-ecological system approach, we are likely to improve the chances of the MSP process succeeding on both the human and nature fronts.},
}
TY - JOUR
AU - Pennino, Maria Grazia
AU - Brodie, Stephanie
AU - Frainer, André
AU - Lopes, Priscila F. M.
AU - Lopez, Jon
AU - Ortega-Cisneros, Kelly
AU - Selim, Samiya Ahmed
AU - Vaidianu, Natasa
TI - The Missing Layers: Integrating Sociocultural Values Into Marine Spatial Planning
T2 - Frontiers in Marine Science
PY - 2021
VL - 8
DO - 10.3389/fmars.2021.633198
AB - Marine Spatial Planning (MSP) is a relatively new approach to ocean management and has been widely implemented worldwide. Ideally, MSP should be established as a public process that analyzes and distributes human activities across space and time to achieve ecological, economic and social goals, which historically have been accomplished exclusively in the political arena. However, in most cases MSP seems to be driven primarily by economic interests rather than by sociocultural goals. In this paper, we discuss how integrating the missing sociocultural layers into MSP can help to reduce governance rigidity, promote adaptability in decision-making, support environmental justice, and improve MSP acceptance and uptake. In particular, we focus on identifying possible points of connection between MSP and frameworks based on social-ecological system theory, including co-management and other democratic and empowering alternatives. We conclude by proposing a new definition of the MSP process that is more inclusive, and mindful of users’ rights and sociocultural objectives. If we bridge the gap between the dominant economic rhetoric and a de facto sociocultural-ecological system approach, we are likely to improve the chances of the MSP process succeeding on both the human and nature fronts.
ER -
